Judge rules case against former Twin Cities pastor can continue

Local News
matthew everly graphic_1545880303253.png.jpg

The lawyer for a former Twin Cities pastor, accused of breaking his infant daughter’s legs and one of her arms, said he plans on putting up a “substantial” and “vigorous” defense.

Defense attorney Scott Kording made the comment in court after McLean County Judge Casey Costigan denied a defense motion for a directed verdict that would have cleared 26-year old Matthew Everly of the accusations.  

Everly was a minister at Normal’s Eastview Christian Church before prosecutors filed 11 charges back in May, including aggravated battery of a child, aggravated domestic battery, and reckless conduct.   

In a courtroom filled with Everly’s supporters, the judge said prosecutors have presented sufficient evidence so far to move forward with the case.  

Judge Costigan mentioned there were three people who had access to baby Olivia, who was two weeks old when she suffered the broken bones. The judge noted Everly tried to minimize his role in the case in his statements to authorities, and a doctor testified she believed the injuries didn’t happen by accident.   

Everly’s lawyer would not say whether he’ll call Everly as a witness.   

The defense presents its case on Monday.   ​


By Howard Packowitz, WJBC

Copyright 2019 Nexstar Broadcasting, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.